I read a blog this morning that just made me mad. I’ve written a bit over the last few months about sections of the sailing industry that believe their sport is somehow inferior. Perhaps its a UK thing to just find the bad news in order to sell more papers or magazines. Perhaps it is easier to play to the whingers than to look a little further for good news and optimism.
Elaine Bunting, writing in a blog for Yachting World headlined her piece ‘Yacht Racing – Dead or Alive?’ What annoys me more than the article’s premise is that YBW.com don’t allow comments on the site. Instead, in typical old fashioned magazine style, you can email the author and they can choose which comments to show or not.
Well, since this is 2009, if they don’t want to let me comment on their site, I will comment on mine. Here are some of the gems from the article.
…sailing is not a pure sport and can never sell to a mass audience as such. There’s no point in comparing ocean racing to rugby or football. Ocean racing is too technical and distant to be followed in the same way.
Goodness knows what the author defines as a ‘pure sport’. The IOC seem to think that sailing is a sport – it has Olympic representation after all – which is more than can be said for rugby. I agree there is no point comparing sailing to what the English call football (s0ccer), as it is just a ball and two goal posts. Amercian football on the other hand is highly technical.
While on the one hand YBW’s Bunting decrys sailing as elitist, she seems to think that the general public is too stupid to understand the technical complexities of sailing. This can be seen as either insulting or ignorant of facts like hundreds of thousands of people playing the Volvo and Vendee online game. Sports fans are not homogenous. Some people follow the ‘technical’ sport of Formula One to see who is fastest over the line, some are glued to live timing and scoring screens and want to know the effect of the latest aerodynamic part on the 2nd sector, some want to see what the driver’s girlfriends are wearing. Why can’t sailing be pitched at the same level?
Ocean racing … has more in common with a polar expedition than a football match.
While this statement is true, wouldn’t a polar expedition be more exciting if there were two teams in the polar expedition, both aiming to be the first to the pole, or the first to discover a new route. Offshore sailing has been compared to climbing Mount Everest, but they don’t race up the North Face.
The author goes on to prove her case with internal statistics.
Reader surveys have been amazingly consistent over the last 20 years, and the answer has always been roughly the same: the percentage of readers who are ‘very interested’ in sports report-style racing coverage is 4%.
What this statistic hides is that readers of YBW magazines are not racers. If you are into racing, you don’t buy Yachting World, or Yachting Monthly you buy Seahorse or Yachts and Yachting. Moreover, in 2009 if you want sports-report style racing coverage you go to the websites of the events. A monthly magazine will struggle to keep people interested when they already know the outcome. By the time Yachting World tells me who won the Sydney Hobart Race, I have already had the winner’s photograph as my computer wallpaper for 3 weeks.
We do agree with YBW’s blogger when she says:
The thing that so many sailing events organisers do not, and will not understand is people are always, invariably, much more richly fascinating than boats. And those sailors who have the skills and abilities to communicate the experience in the most interesting or visceral way will always have a bigger audience.
This is true, but not exclusively a problem for sailing. Compare the American Le Mans Series to NASCAR. In ALMS, the star is the car. They are the latest prototypes made from technically advanced composites running the lastest bio-fuels. As a result the series is pretty boring unless you are an engineer. NASCAR on the other hand uses stock cars. They are not pretty, they are not too technical and yet hundres of thousands of people turn out every week to watch them race – why? Because the drivers are characters. The good ‘ol southern boy against the blue eyed pretty guy from California versus the cranky greece monkey from Detroit. Sailing does need to make the sailors known.
Sports Fans also love a wreck. Just as NASCAR fans secretly want a bunch of cars to go into the wall at turn 4, so too do sailing fans like a bit of drama like a dismasting or a rescue at sea. It’s human nature.
Is Yacht Racing dead? No way. Take a look at the article today about the next generation. To borrow another phrase from the world of NASCAR. “Nobody knows when the first sailboat race was – we think it was when they built the second sailboat.”
Stop putting down the sport that pays you. Find the good news. Accept that things have to change and move on. If it can be done a better way, do it. Enable a proper debate. Embrace the technology. Marvel at the thousands of people who follow yacht racing via new technology.
Yacht Racing is Dead. Long Live Yacht Racing.